Here is a speech that might inspire policymakers in countries that aim at putting markets under strict democratic control to avoid monopolies, booms and busts and extreme concentration of wealth. The speech was published by
Social Europe. The author quotes a Swedish social democrat who once said: “The market is a useful servant, but an intolerable
master”. He stresses that "underlying the demise of neoliberalism is a financial system out of control."
Jón Baldvin Hannibalsson
The neoliberal era started in the eighties as a revolt against the
welfare state. It was a reassertion of the fundamentalist belief in
market infallibility. It turned out to be a repeat version of history:
Essentially it leads to
casino capitalism, in the thrall of
high finance, just as in the stock exchange crash in 1929.
Austerity-like policies to deal with the consequences deepened the
crisis, then as now, and ended in a decade-long Great Depression.
The bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers in 2008 signified the end of that
neoliberal era. Once more, this version of unregulated capitalism
crashed. It ended in the biggest rescue operation by the state in
history. Stimulus packages by the state and quantitative easing
(printing money) by central banks on a massive scale rescued us from a
new Great Depression.
Instead, we are now experiencing the Great Recession. What is the
difference? A massive bail-out of the financial system by tax-payers.
Once again, unregulated capitalism had to be saved from the capitalists –
by the state. This has revealed neoliberalism to be what it is:
pseudo-science in the service of the super-rich. Just like Soviet
communism it is a fundamentalist dogma, which has utterly failed the
test of implementation. And in so far as it is in the service of
privileged elites and rejects the role of the democratic state in taking
care of the public interest it is in essence
anti-democratic.
Dying neoliberalism
Underlying the demise of neoliberalism is a financial system out of
control. In the years 1980-2014 the financial system grew six times
faster than the real economy. The fundamentalist belief driving it is
that the sole duty of corporate CEOs is to maximize
short-term
profits, share prices and dividends. Those perverse incentives are used
to justify executive salaries more than 300 times higher than those of
average workers; and obscene bonuses.
This is many times more than in any other sectors, although managing
money creates no comparable value. As such, this financial system has
turned out to be the main conduit for moving streams of income and
wealth from the productive sectors of society to the financial elite:
from the 99% to the 1%.
The share of labor in global GDP has fallen by hundreds of billions
annually, while the share of income/wealth enriching the 1% has
increased dramatically.
Small and medium-sized companies (SMEs) account for 67% of job
creation in our societies, but receive only a fraction of total bank
lending. In their single-minded pursuit of short-term profit the banks
concentrate their lending on stock exchange speculation and real estate,
increasing the nominal value of existing assets – creating bubbles and
busts – and further enriching the rich.
This is why inequality has reached exorbitant levels in our
societies. The rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer
by the day. This is why long-term unemployment is built into the system.
This is why poverty is increasing amidst plenty. This is why social
cohesion is dwindling and polarisation growing. Since our leaders seem
to be offering no convincing solutions, feelings of disappointment,
resentment, anger and distrust are rising.
Our democracy is under siege by the plutocratic elite.
Footloose finances and solidarity
This unsustainable financial system is footloose and fickle and prone
to panic at the slightest sign of trouble, leaving behind scorched
earth: collapsed currencies, bankrupted banks, sovereign defaults and
mountains of debt
to be paid by others. There is a complete disconnect between
freedom and responsibility.
After the crash of 2008 the system has been rebuilt on the same model.
That means that we are stuck in a prolonged recession, even awaiting a
new crisis. The people out there, who are suffering the consequences,
are waiting for trustworthy solutions –
radical reform.
What is our social democratic response to this existentialist crisis
of unregulated capitalism? The basic elements of the Nordic model took
shape as a response to the great socio-economic upheavals of the
interwar period of the last century. In the West we observed the
market failure
of unregulated capitalism and the Great Depression. In the East we
observed the Soviet experiment with communism: a centralized command
economy run by a police state, which enforced the abolition of human
rights, democracy and the rule of law.
We rejected both. We decided that we would follow
the third way.
We recognized the usefulness of a competitive market system, where
applicable, to allocate resources and create wealth. But we put markets
under strict democratic control to avoid market distortions (monopolies,
booms and busts and extreme concentration of wealth). We insisted on
public provision of education, healthcare and general utilities (energy,
water, public transport, etc).
The means are familiar. Social insurance (sickness, accident, old
age, and unemployment insurance), free access to quality healthcare and
education, paid for by progressive taxation; active labour market policy
to get rid of unemployment; and provide affordable housing for all. We
emphasize equality of the sexes and strong support for families with
children. These are redistributive policies aimed at increasing equality
and social mobility – as a matter of human rights not as charity.
The result is a society where equality of income and wealth is
greater than elsewhere. This means that individual freedom is not a
privilege of the few, but a matter of emancipation for the many. Social
mobility – the ability to advance in society, if you work hard and play
by the rules – is
de facto greater in the Nordic countries than
elsewhere. The Nordic model has by now replaced the United States of
America as the land of opportunity.
This is the only socio-economic model, emerging in the last century,
that has withstood the test of time in the era of globalization in the
21st century.
Why the Nordic model works
The neoliberal creed is that the welfare state, with its high
progressive taxes and strong public sector, is uncompetitive. State
intervention hampers growth and innovation and results in stagnation.
The bottom line: owing to its lack of dynamism, the welfare state is
said to be unsustainable in the long run. And the proliferation of state
bureaucracy is even said to threaten individual freedom and ultimately
end in a totalitarian state (Hayek).
Now we know better. The facts speak for themselves. No matter what
criteria we apply, the Nordic model is invariably at the top of the
league.
This applies no less to economic performance than other criteria:
Economic growth, research and developement, technological innovation,
productivity per hour of work, job creation, participation in the labour
market, (especially women), equality of the sexes, level of education,
social mobility, absence of poverty, health and longevity, quality of
infrastructure, access to unspoilt nature, the overall quality of life.
Less inequality than in most places. And a vibrant democracy. What more
do you want?
What tasks lie ahead? An all-out effort against the financial elite
to restrain the forces of inequality and to reclaim the power of
democracy. An unyielding solidarity with Europe’s youth, who have been
left to fend for themselves in the queues of the unemployed, bereft of
hope. And take up the fight for the preservation of the environment and
our common future on this planet.
There are
three major challenges that lie ahead in the immediate and near future:
- Sanitise the corrupt financial system and put it back firmly under democratic control
- Massive investment in clean and renewable energy to replace fossil
fuels as the life-blood of our economies. This is an urgent task which
calls for social democrats and environmentalists to work together to
save our planet
- Start planning now how to tackle the consequences of the
technological revolution which is ongoing all around us (IT,
digitization and automation)
The prospect of massive and systemic unemployment through
automation
calls for radical thinking about the distribution of income and the
responsibilities of the democratic state in such a society. On the
agenda should be proposals for a minimum
basic income for all.
This is a gigantic task that calls for well-designed redistributive
policies in the spirit of social democracy, utterly beyond the capacity
of unregulated capitalism to solve.
These three major problems, as well as relevant solutions, are
inter-related.. A precondition for success in meeting them is a
political alliance between social democrats, trade unions,
environmentalists and the radical left among Europe´s neglected youth.
The road signs are already there.
Remember the motto of Tage Erlander, the long-time leader of Sweden’s
social democrats, and arguably the greatest reformer of the last
century. He said: “The market is a useful servant, but an intolerable
master”. And the spiritual leader of the Catholic faith, Pope Francis,
agreed, when he said:
The worship of the golden calf of old has found a new and
heartless image in the cult of money and the dictatorship of financial
markets, which are faceless and lacking any humane goal. Money has to
serve, not rule.
This is an edited version of a speech given at the celebratory
120th anniversary of the Lithuanian Social-Demcorati Party in Vilnius.
